Related: Training Pants vs. Pull-Ups – What's the Difference?
At the same time, I fully admit that we ended up using Pull-Ups as the best disposable training pants I could find when we were potty training both our boy and our girl.
In a hurry? Click to get your printable potty training readiness checklist now!
You must be wondering, why am I contradicting myself? Like I explained in my last post about disposable training pants, I was pretty enthusiastic about being a “big boy” and a “big girl” when Haiden and Piper started potty training. I also told them over and over again that they were wearing underwear because they were so big.
You might remember that I emphasized potty training during the day and figured that the nights would work themselves out. Because of that I planned on having both my boy and girl wear diapers at night until they woke up with dry diapers for a consistent number of days.
All my encouraging big boy and big girl talk worked like a charm, but it also backfired on me! The kids were more than willing to put on underwear, but they both started refusing to wear diapers at night.
My solution was disposable training pants for night time only. It worked as a compromise for both of my kids. It also had the added bonus of keeping the bedding dry if they did happen to go potty in the middle of the night.
The best disposable training pants
Potty training my boy, Haiden, only took a few days in the daytime but it took a few weeks of night potty training. We quickly learned what the best disposable training pants for boys were.
The same went for my girl, Piper. I've outlined how to potty train an 18 month girl because it worked for us and it took two weeks. But the overnights potty training went on for a while. Because of that, we also had the pleasure of finding the best disposable training pants for girls!
Right now, though, I'm just going to focus on the best disposable training pants and why parents love them.
Best disposable training pants for nights
I've used all sorts of brands of disposable training pants and I think these are the best:
- Pull-Ups Learning Designs training pants for girls are the best disposable training pants for girls at night.
- Pull-Ups Learning Designs training pants for boys are the best disposable training pants for boys at night.
While the Pull-Ups Learning Designs are the best, I have a few other types of training pants from both Pull-Ups and Easy-Ups:
All of the above have great reviews and they're also excellent candidates for the second best disposable training pants.
The best disposable training pants for day potty training
Are you wondering why there are different recommended training pants for daytime and nights? It's only because some of the training pants and “cool alerts” or react with a cool sensation when they get wet.
That's great for when your child is awake. The cool alert is like a reminder that they went potty and need to be changed. But do any of us want our little ones waking up with a cold bottom? Remember, we want to keep potty training positive, so be patient and gentle with over night potty training. The cool alerts aren't the way to do it at night!
But for the day, the cool alerts might be just what your child needs to stop going potty in her pants. In that case, here are the best disposable training pants for potty training during the day:
- Pull-Ups Cool & Learn Training Pants for girls are the best disposable training pants for girls during the day.
- Pull-Ups Cool & Learn training pants are the best disposable training pants for boys during the day.
The best disposable training pants for big kids
Sometimes big kids need extra protection at night. It's important to make them feel comfortable, not ashamed of it.
You can eliminates the mess and the work associated with nighttime accidents by providing bigger kids with training pants. Why not use them and help everyone feel better about it?
Here are some of the best disposable training pants for big kids:
And remember these great points about bedwetting when you're shopping for disposable training pants for big kids:
The best disposable training pants from store brands
I fully endorse using generic diapers if you can get them for less than name brands (it's often easier to get name brand diapers for less than any store brands on Amazon!), but the same just doesn't seem to be true for disposable training pants.
In the hopes that you'll only be using disposable training pants for a short amount of time, I recommend saving yourself the trouble and buying a brand you can have confidence in.
If you're really wanting store brand training pants here's a summary of recommendations:
Target's Up & Up disposable training pants reviews generally scream not recommended! Check them out for yourself.
Walmart's Parent's Choice disposable training pants have decent but a suspiciously limited number of reviews. Why do these disposable training pants have only 8 or 11 all positive reviews while name brands have thousands of reviews?
The same is true for Walgreens Well Beginnings disposable training pants. The number of reviews is so low – in the single digits – for all of the store brand training pants. Yet the name brands have hundreds of reviews.
In short, there is no best disposable training pants for store brands!
All in all, if you're planning on using disposable training pants during potty training, I hope you're planning on using them for specific circumstances and for a limited amount of time.
If there's one thing to remember, it's this: use disposable training pants as a tool for potty training, don't use them thinking they'll potty train your child for you!
More potty training articles:
Tried and True Books and Movies for Potty Training (tip: it helps to start reading and watching these long before you start potty training!)
Get ready to to potty train: the best potty training set